2020: A Year Of Hunger And Struggle For Migrant Workers

The novel coronavirus, which first emerged in Wuhan, China, left havoc in its wake as it swept across the world in 2020 and the lockdown measures in India has revealed the – sufferings and struggle of the migrant workers. The migrant workers across the nation, in a desperate bid to return home, embarked on long and perilous journeys on foot.

The crisis of hunger among migrant workers is only likely to grow steeper with 50 percent of workers interviewed having rations left for less than a day, according to a study. The ‘21 Days and Counting: COVID-19 Lockdown, Migrant Workers, and the Inadequacy of Welfare Measures in India’ report pointed out 72 per cent of the workers said that their ration would finish in two days.

In Maharashtra, 71 per cent told the Stranded Workers Action Network (SWAN) that they had rations only for a day while 89 per cent had stocks for two days.

However, these are temporary measures that are not sustainable for a period as long as 21 days (and now longer). Even the central government’s announcement of aid to construction workers from the cess collected by labour welfare boards means nothing to the many stranded migrants who aren’t registered.

Only some state governments have recognised the acute distress of those migrants and have started extending relief measures (beyond shelters) for migrants like the supply of free rations to non-ration-card holders (Delhi) and Rs 1000 cash transfers to stranded migrants (Bihar).

Despite some meaningful state orders, the workers’ testimonies at the time they reached out to SWAN volunteers present a sombre picture. Among the states we have received most requests from, the administrative response has so far been most prompt in Karnataka and has been the most patchy in Maharashtra.

  • 50% of workers had rations left for less than 1 day
The situation seems particularly dire in Maharashtra. 71 percent of individuals in Maharashtra (out of 291 groups who were asked) said that they need rations just for 1 day while 89 percent in Maharashtra said that within 2 days all their rations will finish. While no small number, still, as compared, in Karnataka, 36 percent (out of 1212 who were asked this question) reported that they need rations just for 1 day.
  • 96% had not received rations from the government and 70% had not received any cooked food

This is the worst in Uttar Pradesh where none of the workers had received any rations from the govt (out of 1611 who were asked this). On access to cooked food, there’s considerable state-level variation. While in Karnataka 80 percent haven’t been ready to access cooked food, in Punjab only 32 percent didn’t have access to cooked food. The figures from Delhi and Haryana, states which provided the foremost number of cooked meals within the country, also are encouraging. Close to 60 percent of the workers we’ve received calls from said that that they had been ready to access cooked meals.

Sajid Ansari who works in Mumbai said, “We do get cooked food on some days from community kitchens. But the children are falling sick eating it. We want money to buy rations to cook food.”
Rate of Hunger and Distress Exceeding the Rate of Relief
Two weeks into the lockdown, only 1 percent of the stranded workers had received rations from the government and 3 weeks into the lockdown, only 4 percent of them had received rations from the government. For cooked food, we asked if they got cooked from any source, i.e., either government or some local organisation. So, the percentage of people who have not received cooked food from the government is likely to be more than what is reported here.
What the lockdown has revealed is the absence of administrative oversight on the contract labour and lack of accountability of both the employers and the governments.
When 89 percent of the stranded workers have not been paid during the lockdown period by their employers, the directive of the Ministry of Home Affairs asking employers to pay their workers stands nullified. Had the governments maintained information more accurately on where workers are employed, how many of them are employed, by whom etc, then the hunger crisis could have been averted to a great extent.
There have been at least 195 documented lockdown related deaths 13 (compared to 331 COVID-19 related deaths) which include suicides, death during the journey that migrant workers made to their home states and hunger, alcohol withdrawal and police brutality. It is no longer a trade-off between lives and livelihoods but between lives and lives. With neither food nor cash, migrant workers have been pushed to the brink of starvation, alarming levels of vulnerability and extreme indignity.
In UP, 64 percent of workers had not received any cooked food from the government

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

×